Critique My Query

E-mail Article to a FriendPrint ArticleBookmark and Share

Journey of a Killer, a novel

AN EVALUATION OF A QUERY LETTER FOR A BOOK

By Marla Miller
Published: June 20, 2011
Marla Miller
Marla Miller
The query letter

Dear Ms. Miller:

I watched your review of the query letter for The Ugandan Affair on The Writer website, and upon reading the submitted letter, agreed with your assessment of it. I value your opinion and would like to have my query letter critiqued as well.
 
“Retreat, plan, attack.” Three simple words passed from father to daughter that become Sunny Whitaker’s mantra. Her father, Daniel, the son of a New York mob enforcer, teaches her that revenge is an acceptable response to those who hurt her or do her an injustice. She learns her lessons so well that when she commits her first murder at the age of 12, he compliments her on a job well done, and she uses his words to justify her future actions. But it is her husband’s killing that causes her to run from the police and begin to reflect on her life and wonder if her father’s teachings were, in fact, correct.
 
From the betrayal by her first love, to her marriage to a prominent attorney, Sunny’s 39-year journey crosses all the lines of human experience, while still leaving her with hope for the future. Journey of a Killer is a character-driven story of love and murder (93,330 words) that explores the question: How much of what we know comes from our parents, and how right are those teachings?
 
Three of my short stories have been published: one in [Blank], one as a winning entry in [Blank] contest, and one through my writers group, which published an anthology of its members’ stories. In addition to taking several writing classes, I recently participated in [Blank] agent panel.
 
If you’d like to read my completed manuscript, please contact me, and I will happy to send it to you. Thank you for your time.
 
Sincerely,

[Name withheld]

The critique


Want Marla to critique your book query?

Send your query letter to marketingthemuse@gmail.com. Be sure to use the subject line "The Writer Query Letter Critique." Queries for nonfiction and fiction (all genres) are welcome, and critiques are free.

Marla Miller, a writer herself, teaches Marketing the Muse Workshops at the Southern California Writers' Conference and the Santa Barbara Writers Conference. Her Quick Query Critique video segments are available at marlamiller.com.
User Comments
Only registered members of WriterMag.com are allowed to comment on this article. Registration is FREE and only takes a couple minutes.

Register Today!
 
DEANNA R ADAMS from OHIO said:
I would be turned off pretty early in the book discovering that the main protagonist (who I'd want to like) is a murderer, beginning at 12! Sorry, but a bit too disturbing for me. Does she have any redeeming qualities?
5 stars
PATRICIA STARZYK from WASHINGTON said:
RE: The unreliable narrator. Do we know that Sunny is the narrator of this story? I couldn't find that anywhere in the letter. Maybe it's by the third person impartial observer, which would make it an entirely different story. I agree that it would have helped the evaluation if the author had providded more details about what kind of book this was.
MARLA MILLER from CALIFORNIA said:
Don't you all just love the opportunity to share our opinions on what makes a query letter HOOK!
Great comments here----remember this, when writing fiction, the author's job with the world s/he creates is to make us-the reader-suspend our disbelief.
Its simplest definition (for me) is this: Could this have happened? OMG, it could in the world this author created!
5 stars
PETE PETERSON from CALIFORNIA said:
Again, Miss Miller, you hit a home run on a good pitch! Your critique contains much solid information, and you correctly pinned down the same questions I had. For some reason, I thought a Journey of a Killer was/is a work of fiction. Nevertheless, your remarks still stand. I too, wondered at the time frame involved; I also wondered were it started, i.e., at her first murder (age 12), or as a child (at her father's knee, so to speak) and where it ends. Good stuff!
3 stars
ALICE POYNOR from SOUTH CAROLINA said:
Yes, I agree. the third paragraph is the weak link here. Not sure what "crosses the lines of human experience" means and, "character-driven" sounds like she is saying that because that's what we're told fiction is supposed to be, whether or not it really is. Sounds intriguing, but the query by itself, wouldn't bite me.
12
Free Newsletter
Get our free newsletter